Middle Spoon follows a narrator who seems to have it all—a devoted husband, two children, and a younger boyfriend—until the boyfriend unexpectedly leaves. Grappling with his first intense heartbreak, he confronts social judgment and the limits of how relationships and family can be arranged while searching for a way to hold love and responsibility together. Witty and empathetic, the novel examines modern intimacy, polyamory, and the messy work of wanting and belonging.

Mel, a bartender at a chic New York City cocktail lounge, has always been skeptical about love, especially after witnessing countless failed dates. Her perspective shifts when she meets Bebe, a captivating woman with a passion for whiskey, who is in an open marriage with her partner, Kade. Intrigued by Bebe's proposal for a date, Mel embarks on a journey of self-discovery and romance. As she navigates this new relationship, Mel finds herself exploring deeper connections with both Bebe and Kade, challenging her previous notions of love. Along the way, she gains the confidence to pursue her dream of opening her own bar, realizing that love can be more expansive and fulfilling than she ever imagined.

Set against the backdrop of modern America, this compelling narrative delves into the intricate dynamics of polyamorous relationships, exploring the emotional, social, and cultural challenges faced by those who choose to love beyond traditional boundaries. The story follows a diverse group of individuals as they navigate the complexities of love, trust, and communication, offering a nuanced perspective on the joys and struggles of maintaining multiple romantic connections. Through their intertwined lives, the book sheds light on the evolving nature of love and the courage it takes to defy societal norms in pursuit of authentic connections.