Batman #617 by Jeph Loeb

Amid the escalating Hush conspiracy, he’s lured to Crime Alley and the cemetery, where a masked assailant who looks and fights like the long-dead Jason Todd ambushes him. The vicious, deeply personal confrontation forces him to relive old guilt and question what’s real as his opponent taunts him with intimate knowledge of their past. Shaken but not broken, he recognizes the encounter as another cruel manipulation and steels himself to cut through the deception and end the mastermind’s game.