Mister Death's Blue Eyed Girls by Mary Downing Hahn

A teenage narrator recounts how her close-knit small town is shattered when two bright, blue-eyed girls are found murdered; as the police search for a stranger, suspicion, fear, and distrust spread through the community. Haunted by survivor’s guilt and the limits of memory, she revisits friendships, rumors, and the slow, painful process of grieving while trying to make sense of senseless violence and her own complicity. The story examines how loss reshapes identities, reveals hidden cruelties, and leaves a lingering need for truth and healing.

Purchase from Bookshop.org