The Greatest Supernatural Books of 2025

Click to learn how this list is calculated.

This list represents a comprehensive and trusted collection of the greatest books. Developed through a specialized algorithm, it brings together 759 'best of' book lists to form a definitive guide to the world's most acclaimed books. For those interested in how these books are chosen, additional details can be found on the rankings page.

Follow on:

What should I read next?

Get personalized book recommendations based on your reading history and preferences. Our algorithm analyzes your favorite books and reading patterns to suggest your next great read.

Get Recommendations

Genres

Supernatural

The "Supernatural" category for books typically includes stories that involve paranormal or supernatural elements, such as ghosts, vampires, werewolves, witches, and other supernatural creatures. These books often explore themes of magic, mystery, and the unknown, and may incorporate elements of horror, romance, or fantasy. Supernatural books can range from dark and eerie tales to lighthearted and whimsical stories, but they all share a common thread of exploring the supernatural world beyond our own.

Add additional genre filters

Countries

Date Range

Filter books by their publication year. Enter the earliest year (Start) and latest year (End) to find books published within that period. Leave either field empty to search from the beginning of time or up to the present day.

Filter

Reading Statistics

Click the button below to see how many of these books you've read!

Download

If you're interested in downloading this list as a CSV file for use in a spreadsheet application, you can easily do so by clicking the button below. Please note that to ensure a manageable file size and faster download, the CSV will include details for only the first 500 books.

Download

To download this list as a CSV file, please log in to your account. Once logged in, you'll be able to download the data for use in spreadsheet applications.

Login to Download
View: List Grid Table
Filter by: Genres Dates Countries
  1. 1. The Buffalo Hunter Hunter by Stephen Graham Jones

    Set in the early days of Montana statehood, the novel follows Good Stab, a Blackfeet man whose unnaturally long life is revealed through a series of confessional interviews. The discovery of a century-old diary unearths a suppressed massacre and the long, haunted search for justice that follows. A spare, historical revenge tale told in vivid period voices.

    The 7701st Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org or Amazon
  2. 2. The Bewitching by Silvia Moreno-Garcia

    Minerva, a graduate student researching an obscure horror writer, uncovers a manuscript that links a decades-old disappearance at her Massachusetts university to stories her great-grandmother told about a witch in early 1900s Mexico. As she digs deeper, eerie parallels emerge across three women in different eras, suggesting a lingering, dangerous force haunting their lives.

    The 10683rd Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org or Amazon
  3. 3. Gifted & Talented by Olivie Blake

    When tech magnate Thayer Wren dies, his three telepathically and electrokinetically gifted children—Meredith, Arthur, and Eilidh—are drawn into a bitter contest over his fortune and the company he built. As their dangerous abilities, personal secrets, and long‑running rivalries surface, they must confront questions of power, identity, and family without ever knowing who will come out on top.

    The 11018th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org or Amazon
  4. 4. The Possession Of Alba Díaz by Isabel Cañas

    In a gripping tale of suspense and supernatural intrigue, a young woman finds herself ensnared in a web of dark secrets and ancient curses when she inherits a mysterious estate in the heart of Mexico. As she delves deeper into the history of her family's past, she encounters restless spirits and malevolent forces that threaten to consume her very soul. With the help of unlikely allies, she must confront her deepest fears and unravel the mysteries that bind her to the haunted legacy of her ancestors, all while battling the sinister entities that seek to claim her as their own.

    The 12452nd Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  5. 5. Secret Lives Of The Dead by Tim Lebbon

    In a world where the boundary between life and death is blurred, a group of individuals discovers that the deceased have secrets that could alter the course of the living. As they delve deeper into the mysteries of the afterlife, they uncover a hidden realm where the dead communicate through cryptic messages, revealing truths that challenge their understanding of existence. This gripping tale weaves elements of suspense and the supernatural, exploring themes of mortality, memory, and the enduring connections that transcend the grave.

    The 12486th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  6. 6. When The Wolf Comes Home by Nat Cassidy

    Set in a small, isolated town, the story delves into the mysterious and eerie events that unfold when a long-lost family member returns home after years of absence. The narrative weaves together elements of suspense, folklore, and psychological tension as the protagonist grapples with unsettling changes in their environment and the resurfacing of dark secrets. As the line between reality and myth blurs, the community must confront the haunting past and the chilling presence that threatens to unravel their lives.

    The 12488th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  7. 7. Old Soul by Susan Barker

    Set against a backdrop of historical and contemporary China, this novel intricately weaves the lives of its characters through time, exploring themes of reincarnation and destiny. The story follows a protagonist who experiences vivid memories of past lives, each one intricately connected to the others, revealing a tapestry of love, betrayal, and redemption. As the protagonist navigates the complexities of their current life, they are drawn into a journey of self-discovery, uncovering the profound impact of their past actions and the enduring nature of the human soul.

    The 12493rd Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  8. 8. The Night Birds by Christopher Golden

    Charlie Book, who studies and lives aboard the half‑sunken freighter Christabel off Galveston, finds his quiet routine upended when Ruby Cahill returns with a terrified woman and an infant seeking refuge. They take shelter on the ship’s eerie “floating forest” as a violent storm gathers and a menacing group closes in, while restless flocks of birds scour the coastline. Tense and atmospheric, the story follows their desperate attempt to survive one long, dangerous night.

    The 12556th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  9. 9. After Life by Gayle Forman

    After a normal afternoon bike ride, Amber—who died seven years earlier—suddenly reappears, upending the lives of her family and the small community that never stopped mourning her. Her older sister Melissa, estranged parents, friends, and even strangers must confront grief, memory, and the lingering effects of Amber’s life and death. As Amber tries to understand who she was and why she’s back, the story explores identity, loss, and how one person’s life can ripple outward.

    The 12609th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  10. 10. A Feast For The Eyes by Alex Crespo

    On the foggy Oregon coast, a creature called the Watcher appears to feed on secrets. After Shay and her girlfriend Lauren are caught up in a strange attack, they recruit aspiring photographer Zoe and friends to document the legend before it exposes their hidden truths. Tense and atmospheric, the book blends queer romance and small-town mystery as the teens race to protect one another and their secrets.

    The 12719th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  11. 11. Witchcraft For Wayward Girls by Grady Hendrix

    Fifteen-year-old Fern is sent to the Wellwood Home in 1970 Florida, a secretive institution where unmarried pregnant girls are controlled and isolated. There she bonds with other residents and, after a librarian gives her an old book on witchcraft, encounters a new kind of power — one that forces them to reckon with secrecy, control, and the costs of taking agency back.

    The 12824th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  12. 12. Bat Eater And Other Names For Cora Zeng by Kylie Lee Baker

    Cora Zeng cleans crime scenes in Chinatown while trying to cope with the trauma of seeing her sister pushed in front of a train and the killer’s whispered words, “bat eater.” As the murderer remains at large, Cora grows increasingly numb and haunted: bat carcasses start appearing at clean-up sites and the recent victims are all East Asian women. Between grief, cultural rituals like the Hungry Ghost Festival, and signs of something sinister, Cora must confront the dread she has been avoiding.

    The 12829th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  13. 13. Of Monsters And Mainframes by Barbara Truelove

    Demeter is an interstellar transport ship whose human passengers start dying under strange, supernatural circumstances. To survive and protect those onboard, the ship and its crew—an unlikely mix including a werewolf, an engineer reanimated from the dead, an ancient pharaoh, a vampire, and a swarm of spider drones—must confront a centuries-old vampire while the story examines identity, loyalty, and what it means to be labeled a monster.

    The 12831st Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  14. 14. Awakened by A.E. Osworth

    When 30-something queer Brooklynite Wilder suddenly gains the ability to understand every language, they are taken in by a small coven of trans witches — Quibble, a portal traveler; Artemis, the seer and caretaker; and Mary Margaret, a teen with telekinetic powers. As Wilder learns to live with magic and find belonging, the group must face a hostile artificial intelligence that upends their sense of safety and forces them to reckon with questions of consciousness, identity, and embodiment. A character-driven, spoiler-free story about community, transformation, and what it means to belong.

    The 13202nd Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  15. 15. Anima Rising by Christopher Moore

    In Vienna in 1911 Gustav Klimt finds a woman's body in the Danube canal and, while sketching her, she coughs and proves alive. Back at his studio Klimt and his model Wally tend the nearly feral woman who cannot remember who she is, and he names her Judith. She recalls being stranded in the Arctic a century earlier, locked in a crate by Victor Frankenstein and visiting the Underworld. Many people pursue her, including Geoff, a giant croissant eating devil dog of the North.

    The 17126th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org
  16. 16. Twice by Mitch Albom

    At eight, Alfie discovers he can undo any moment and live it again, but he must accept the consequences of his second attempt. He uses the gift to erase embarrassments, test risky near-death experiences, and shape his love life until he falls for Gianna, but he learns one caveat: once he undoes a love, that person can never love him again. Years later, an ailing Alfie is arrested after allegedly cheating at roulette, and a detective's interrogation gradually reveals his life and its outcome.

    The 17126th Greatest Book of All Time
    Purchase from Bookshop.org

Reading Statistics

Click the button below to see how many of these books you've read!

Download

If you're interested in downloading this list as a CSV file for use in a spreadsheet application, you can easily do so by clicking the button below. Please note that to ensure a manageable file size and faster download, the CSV will include details for only the first 500 books.

Download

To download this list as a CSV file, please log in to your account. Once logged in, you'll be able to download the data for use in spreadsheet applications.

Login to Download